How much is a 1909 1909 American Caramel (E91 B) John McGraw #NNO worth?

As of 1985, Rawcomps has tracked 0 raw-condition sales for the 1909 1909 American Caramel (E91 B) #NNO John McGraw. Condition, original ownership provenance, and presence of an original wrapper or pack provenance all materially shift the market when sales do appear. Source: https://www.psacard.com/auctionprices

What's the difference between graded and raw 1909 1909 American Caramel (E91 B) #NNO?

Graded copies of the 1909 1909 American Caramel (E91 B) #NNO are sealed in PSA, SGC, or BGS holders with an assigned condition grade on a 1–10 scale; raw copies are ungraded and the buyer assesses condition directly. Graded copies typically command a premium because the holder authenticates and grades the card in one step — but for raw cards, the upside is condition-judgment that beats the grader's eye. Source: https://www.psacard.com/services/grading

Is my 1909 1909 American Caramel (E91 B) #NNO a reprint?

Reprints exist for nearly every popular pre-1980 baseball card (including the 1909 1909 American Caramel (E91 B) John McGraw). Originals show period-appropriate cardstock thickness, an offset-printing dot pattern visible under a 10× loupe, and back-design fidelity matching the era's printing process. If the card has modern gloss, sharp uncreased corners on a card that should show 76+ years of age, or paper that feels too white and crisp, treat it as a reprint until verified by a professional grading service. Source: https://www.psacard.com/services/authentication

1909 American Caramel (E91 B) · #NNO

John McGraw

Comp signal

Single Source

medium

Total comps

Raw

Graded

30d median

—

Condition-aware breakdown

red

Raw by condition

Poorn=2$159

Graded — by grader & grade

No graded sales

Set: 1909 American Caramel (E91 B)
Year: 1909
Card #: NNO
Set code: 1909_AMERICAN_CARAMEL_E91_B

Sold-market evidence

All sales

Date	Price	Grade	Marketplace	Source
Jun 24, 2026	$159	raw:POOR	eBay	View evidence ↗

$159

raw:POOR

Evidence ↗

Jun 24, 2026 · eBay

Showing 1 of 1 retained sale records. Aggregate totals may include up to 2 qualifying comps; this table is capped at the latest 50 display-eligible rows. Undated evidence is kept and listed after dated sales.

Population

Research pending — Rawcomps does not yet have a verified, card-level grading-population join for this record.

Continue exploring

More John McGraw cards →

1909 Dockman & Sons Gum E92 · #NNOJohn McGraw2 comps
1909 Niagara Baking (D355) · #NNOJohn McGrawcatalogued
1909 Croft's Candy E92 · #NNOJohn McGrawcatalogued
1909 Croft's Cocoa E92 · #NNOJohn McGrawcatalogued
1909 W555 Strip Cards · #NNOJohn McGrawcatalogued
1910 Standard Caramel (E93) · #NNOJohn McGraw4 comps
1910 13 Red Cross Tobacco (T215) · #NNOJohn McGrawcatalogued
1911 16 People's Tobacco Mino (T216) · #NNOJohn McGraw2 comps

All sales

More from 1909 American Caramel (E91 B) →

More John McGraw cards →