Hoyt Wilhelm

Dossier
James Hoyt Wilhelm (July 26, 1922 – August 23, 2002), nicknamed "Old Sarge," was an American professional baseball pitcher in Major League Baseball who played from 1952 to 1972. Wilhelm grew up in North Carolina and fought in World War II before spending several years in the minor leagues, beginning his major league career at the age of 29.
Over two decades he pitched for the New York Giants, St. Louis Cardinals, Cleveland Indians, Baltimore Orioles, Chicago White Sox, California Angels, Atlanta Braves, Chicago Cubs, and Los Angeles Dodgers. He was best known for his knuckleball, which enabled his great longevity. Though he appeared occasionally as a starting pitcher, he worked mainly in relief. Wilhelm won 124 games in relief, which remains the major league record as of 2026. He was the first pitcher to reach 200 saves and the first to appear in 1,000 games.
Wilhelm was nearly 30 when he entered the major leagues and pitched until he was nearly 50. He retired with a career earned run average of 2.52, among the lowest in baseball history. After retiring as a player in 1972, he held longtime coaching jobs with the New York Yankees. Wilhelm was elected to the Baseball Hall of Fame in 1985.
Banked sales
$382K
$382,246
Total comps
4,531
across all sources
Cards catalogued
67
61 with sold comps
Median card
$27
$12 – $58 interquartile
Card gallery
Hoyt Wilhelm through the years
Real catalogue scans. Market figures appear only where sold comps exist.
Top cards by comp volume
Top 10
- 011954Topps · #36242 sales$50
- 021956Topps · #307234 sales$42
- 031953Topps · #151221 sales$69
- 041959Jay Publishing All Star Picture Pack Set A · #nno205 sales$23
- 051959Jay Publishing All Star Picture Pack Set B · #nno205 sales$23
- 061959Jay Publishing Baltimore Orioles Picture Pack Set A · #nno205 sales$23
- 071957Baltimore Orioles Photocards · #nno201 sales$29
- 081957St Louis Cardinals Postcards · #nno201 sales$29
- 091957Topps · #203201 sales$29
- 101960Topps Venezuelan · #nno194 sales$25
The catalogue
Every catalogued card
67 cards
































































