Rawcomps
NFLGauntlet · PASS

Jim Mutscheller

Jim Mutscheller card — 1956
1956

Dossier

James "Bucky" Mutscheller (March 31, 1930 – April 10, 2015) was an American professional football player who played tight end and split end for nine seasons with the Baltimore Colts of the National Football League. He played college football for the Notre Dame Fighting Irish.

Born in Beaver Falls, Pennsylvania, Mutscheller played football, basketball, and baseball at Beaver Falls High School. In the first football game of the 1947 season, he had a 49-yard touchdown reception and a 77-yard touchdown run against Erie East High School, in a game played before 7,000 spectators. He was commonly known as "Bucky" from the time he was in high school.

A pass catcher and run blocker, Mutscheller was a starter for the 1958–59 Colts teams that captured the first two NFL championships in franchise history. He led the league in touchdown receptions, with eight, during the 1957 season, which marked the only Pro Bowl selection of his career.

In 1976, Mutscheller was inducted into the Beaver County Sports Hall of Fame. He died on April 10, 2015.

Banked sales

$696

$696

Total comps

3

across all sources

Cards catalogued

9

2 with sold comps

Median card

$34

$25$340 interquartile

Card gallery

Real catalogue scans. Market figures appear only where sold comps exist.

1957 Topps #103 Jim Mutscheller

$340 median

1957 Topps · #103

2 verified sales

1 / 9

Top cards by comp volume

Top 2

  1. 011957Topps · #1032 sales$340
  2. 021959Topps · #891 sales$16

The catalogue

Every catalogued card

9 cards

1956

1 card

1957

1 card

1958

1 card

1959

1 card

1960

1 card

1961

3 cards

1962

1 card